News releases

SRA approves new Qualified Assurance Scheme for Criminal Advocates

Proposals for a radical overhaul of quality standards for criminal advocates have been approved by the SRA Board today, Wednesday 1 June, subject to assurances on a few key issues.

The Quality Assurance Scheme for Advocates (Criminal) has been developed by the Joint Advocacy Group (JAG), comprising the Solicitors Regulation Authority, Bar Standards Board, and IPS (ILEX Professional Standards). The review is based on Lord Carter's 2006 report calling for a 'client-driven need for the quality assurance of advocacy' as a vital part of an effective justice system.

The SRA Board welcomed the proposed scheme. In approving it, it sought assurances on preparations for judicial training, the costs of the scheme, and the need to ensure that advocates acting in cases before judges involved in their evaluation were not faced with any apparent conflict interests.

If approved by all three bodies, the proposals will be submitted to the Legal Services Board for initial approval in July and full submission in September, with a view to the scheme being introduced in phases from January 2012. It will be considered by the Bar Standards Board on 16 June and IPS (ILEX Professional Standards) will be considering the necessary Rule changes at their meeting in July.

SRA chief executive, Antony Townsend said: "Currently those who undertake advocacy in the criminal courts may have qualified through different routes with varying methods of education, training and assessment.

"While this system may have worked in the past, lawyers, clients, the public and the judiciary, need to be satisfied that advocates appearing in the criminal courts are operating to consistent standards. The changing face of the legal landscape, coupled with competition and commercial issues are all creating pressures which mean that we need to take a more proactive approach - both in the public interest and for consumer protection - to ensure that advocates are competent and able to perform well.

"The Joint Advocacy Group has worked hard since it was formed in late 2009, to develop a credible and durable scheme which will fulfil this need and which is consistent with the regulatory objectives set out in the Legal Services Act 2007. This has included two consultations with the profession. We hope therefore that the SRA Board, and those of our partners, will give their approval so that we may progress within the agreed timescales."

JAG is intending to pilot aspects of the scheme at two court centres, in Canterbury and Durham in May and June, to test its effectiveness for criminal advocates in a range of cases at different levels and to see the extent to which the training programme has prepared the judges to conduct the evaluation.

The number of advocates affected by the scheme within each of the three regulators ranges from a small number of IPS advocates at level 1 to thousands of higher rights solicitors and barristers seeking to practise at levels 3 and 4.

The proposals relate only to the application of the scheme to criminal advocacy although it provides a model which could be used in other areas of advocacy if required.

If approved the first stage of the scheme for initial accreditation of advocates at levels 3 and 4 will become operational in January 2012. Live assessment of advocates at levels 3 and 4, either by judicial evaluation or by an assessment organisation, will begin in March 2012.


Note to editors

Media information:-

For SRA: Lesley Miller – - 01926 487156/07791 162186

For BSB: Rachel Podolak - - 0207 611 1409

For IPS: Paul Hutchinson - - 01234 845710  

Print page to PDF